The NCAA transfer portal was introduced with the promise of providing student-athletes with greater freedom and opportunities. At its best, it facilitates mobility, allowing players to find better fits for their talents and ambitions while enabling programs to strengthen their rosters. However, beneath this seemingly progressive system lies a darker reality that is affecting the lives of thousands of college athletes.
According to a recent ESPN article, there are still 1,200 unsigned FBS scholarship football players—athletes who entered the transfer portal with hopes of finding better opportunities but now find themselves without a team. That’s one-third of all FBS scholarship players who entered the portal.
The ESPN article detailed that since tampering is rampant, players with agents or representatives have a significant advantage, receiving offers and visits lined up the moment they enter the portal. Conversely, athletes who follow the rules find themselves starting their recruitment from scratch when the portal opens.
This situation is particularly sad for players who didn’t voluntarily enter the portal. Some are nudged out by coaching staffs with veiled suggestions like, “You’ll never play here.” Others receive poor advice from family members or unscrupulous agents.
The Scholarship Dilemma
Another harsh consequence of the transfer portal is the loss of scholarship security. Once a player enters the portal, their current school’s scholarship obligation can end by the start of the next semester. If they can’t secure a new opportunity, they can be left without a team and the financial means to continue their education. 30 to 40% of all Division I athletes who enter the portal do not find new homes at Division I schools. Some drop to lower divisions, while others leave college sports altogether because they can’t afford tuition without a scholarship.
Considering that the vast majority of college athletes will never play professionally, the primary benefit of a collegiate athletic scholarship is education. Losing that opportunity not only affects an athlete’s immediate future but can have long-term consequences for their career and life trajectory.
What Can Be Done?
- Regulating Agents and Representatives: In professional sports like the NFL, agents must be certified by organizations like the NFLPA to represent players. Could the NCAA implement a similar system to protect student-athletes from bad actors?
- Holding Programs Accountable: Schools and coaches should not be able to pressure players into the portal without repercussions. Transparent policies and reporting mechanisms could help identify and address such behavior.
- Improved Leadership: The NCAA’s leadership is ineffective. The creation of dedicated commissioners for sports like football and basketball could provide the competent leadership needed to address these issues.
Wheelhouse Blog 